At any rate, the promise to make it clear how selfconstitution should be considered to be action itself p. Agency, identity, and integrity is a philosophical book by christine korsgaard, in which the author sets out to demonstrate how people determine their own actions. Selfconstitution agency, identity, and integrity christine m. Nov 06, 2012 universal recognition of inalienable right to selfdetermination most effective way of guaranteeing fundamental freedoms, third committee told. Korsgaard is responding to such philosophers as harry frankfurt who make desire central to their account of personhood. The core argument of the paper is that the modern philosophical notion of self constitution is directed against the prospect of human beings. Korsgaard presents an account of the foundation of practical reason and moral obligation. The constitution of the democratic peoples republic of korea preamble the democratic peoples republic of korea is the socialist motherland of juche where the ideas and leadership of the great leaders comrade kim il sung and comrade kim jong il are applied. Korsgaard furthermore speaks of the process of self constitution as involving the selection of certain social roles, and of fulfi lling such roles with integrity and dedication. The constitution of norway, as laid down on 17 may 1814 by the constituent. Mar 26, 2009 korsgaard develops a theory of action and of interaction, and of the form interaction must take if we are to have the integrity that, she argues, is essential for agency. She is aware of the apparent problem that ensues from this position, which she presents in the guise of the paradox of self constitution, namely.
The normative constitution of agency the harvard community has made this article openly available. The challenge of selfdetermination and emerging nationalism. Norway in accordance with its constitution and laws so help me god, the. While sensitive to why these criticisms have occurred to so many people, korsgaard demonstrates in careful stepbystep explication of kants dominant concerns self constitution, the commitment to freedom, and the inseparability of these ideashow thoroughly beside the point most antikantian objections have been. For more information on dark deposits, see our faq. What is the relationship between the self and normativity. The second edition is a major step forwardmuch exciting new work has been done in this area in the last 10 years. Korsgaard s latest book, self constitution, develops and defends the broadly kantian account of action and agency that hovers. This volume collects ten influential papers by christine m. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading self constitution. Everyone interested in the construction of the self should read this book. How to make something of yourself without being all that you can be. Agency, identity, and integrity find, read and cite all the research you need. A dialogue with immanuel kant takes place throughout the book.
Moral philosophy aspires to understand the fact that human actions, unlike the actions of the other animals, can be morally good or bad. The result of this amendment is that there are now two equal norwegian language versions of the constitution one in bokmal and one in nynorsk. Amendment to the united states constitution provides an individual the right to possess a firearm, and to use that weapon for traditional lawful purposes, including self defense within the home. She has defended a version of this view in her book the sources of normativity cambridge up, 1996. They are organized into three parts, and preceded by a very rich introduction, which. Not surprisingly, the concept of selfconstitution is integral to its development.
An original theory of the foundation of practical reason and moral obligation. Plato and kant advance a constitutional model of the soul, in which reason and appetite or passion have different structural and functional roles in the generation of motivation, as opposed to the familiar combat model in which they are portrayed as independent sources of motivation struggling for control. Norways constitution of 1814 with amendments through 2014. Selfconstitution and the existential crisis as mentioned in the introduction, i find that korsgaard s account of selfconstitution and the existentialist theories share many aspects.
The meaning and range of the principle of selfdetermination. Christine korsgaard claims that kantian moral law means the law of self constitution and that unless we fully understand what self constitution means in kant, we cannot comprehend kantian morality. Korsgaard s idea of self constitution is based on the idea that the unity of an action and the unity of an. Kazakhstans constitution of 1995 with amendments through 2011. On that note, it is evident that we know little about our rights in the indian constitution when it comes to self defence.
Two conceptions of agency the original aim of this paper was to throw some light on the question whether, when people act together, there is. A commentary on christine korsgaard s the constitution of agency and self constitution. For those born before the year 1990 it shall nevertheless be the case that a male shall take precedence over a female. As christine korsgaard describes this process in her book selfconstitution. And while the declaration articulates the law of self government, the constitution in turn reflects the application of this law in a variety of contexts, one of which is found in the second amendment. On the basis of that theory, she argues that only morally good action can serve the function of action, which is self constitution. Pdf accepted manuscript requires a pdf viewer such as gsview, xpdf or adobe. What she means by this is that if a rational agent has a reason to perform some action, it is a reason that has normative force for everyone who is a rational agent. Phd thesis, the london school of economics and political science lse. Agency, identity, and integrity english edition ebook. Your story matters citation korsgaard, christine m. Agency, identity, and integrity has somehow been able to add to the mix that includes, say, somewhat carefully argued flapdoodle, an almost unintelligbly argued flapdoodle.
Universal recognition of inalienable right to self. However, it is evident that some existentialist issues might challenge korsgaard s conception of selfconstitution. Korsgaard, one of todays leading moral philosophers. Form of government and religion article 1 the kingdom of norway is a free, independent, indivisible and inalienable realm. The constitution of the kingdom of norway the constitution, as laid down on 17 may 1814 by the constituent assembly at eidsvoll with subsequent amendments, the most recent being of 19 june 1992 a. Mar 01, 2009 as if the disaster that has been my foray into contemporary moral theory has not been colorful enough, christine korsgaards self constitution. Agency, identity, and integrity by korsgaard, christine m. It is a highly engaging attempt to answer what she calls the normative question, which is the question of what could justify moralitys demands. Korsgaard also argues in self constitution that when we will a course of action, we must do so in the form of a determinate commitment. View academics in korsgaard self constitution on academia. Self constitution agency, identity, and integrity christine m. In self constitution, christine korsgaard continues to pursue a neokantian project that attempts to ground morality in constitutive features of human agency and the self. The kantian imperatives as constitutive principles of. Korsgaard, selfconstitution in the ethics of plato and kant.
Agency, identity, and integrity the constitution of agency. Plato and kant advance a constitutional model of the soul, in which reason and appetite or passion have different structural and functional roles in the generation of. The constitutional model makes it possible to explain what makes an action different from an event. Mills, james robert 2009 the challenge of selfdetermination and emerging nationalism. Agency, identity, and integrity oxford scholarship. Korsgaard, 0191569674, 9780191569678, oxford university press, 2009. The work addresses the connection between ethnic identity, right to self determination, constitution making and state restructuring, offering possible ways forward for nepal.
Agency, identity, and integrity korsgaard, christine m. Agency, identity, and integrity kindle edition by korsgaard, christine m download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. But what korsgaard means by self constitution is as much self maintenance as self creation. Abstract this article argues that christine korsgaard gives two accounts of maxims, the identity. In selfconstitution, christine korsgaard continues to pursue a neokantian project that attempts to ground morality in constitutive features of human agency and. Indeed, the court said, there is a constitutional right to selfdefense, for three related reasons reason 1 got. Pdf korsgaard on selfconstitution zeynep talay turner. But were one to think of what korsgaard has in mind by self constitution as what kierkegaard calls self creation, then one would not be too far off. The law of self government is thus vitally important to any discussion of self defense. Selfgovernment and the unalienable right to selfdefense. Published for the most part during the decade 19932003, the essays in this collection represent a bridge between korsgaard s the sources of normativity sn, and her self constitution sc. The outcome of this work is a paper called selfknowledge as an ethical concept. Selfconstituted definition of selfconstituted by the free.
The right to national selfdetermination within the eu. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Constitution in the ethics of plato and kant oxford. Korsgaard develops a theory of action and of interaction, and of the form interaction must take if we are to have the integrity that, she argues, isessential for agency. Constitution, christine korsgaard continues to pursue a neo. On the basis of that theory, she argues that only morally good action can serve the function of action, which is selfconstitution. Harter offers a masterful summary and critique of this work. Abstract christine korsgaard claims that kantian moral law means the law of self constitution and that unless we fully understand what self constitution means in kant, we cannot comprehend kantian morality. Oct 27, 2017 so, for korsgaard, the concept of selfconstitution has many aspects that are interrelated. Dec 26, 2014 that cant be right, and the washington court of appeals said it wasnt right. As if the disaster that has been my foray into contemporary moral theory has not been colorful enough, christine korsgaards selfconstitution.
Yet considerable evidence from cognitivesocial psychology indicates that individuals are often motivated to maintain consistency. Previously the language and spelling in the constitution were based on a relatively conservative normalization of the language that was carried out in 1903. The core argument of the paper is that the modern philosophical notion of selfconstitution is directed against the prospect of human beings. The constitution of the united states preamble we the people of the united states, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do. Kantian project that attempts to ground morality in constitutive features of human agency and the self. Elijah millgram 2011 australasian journal of philosophy 89 3.
Korsgaard develops a theory of action and of interaction, and of the form interaction must take if we are to have the integrity that, she argues, is essential for. Korsgaard, 9780199552801, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. The constitutional topics pages at the site are presented to delve deeper into topics than can be provided on the glossary page or in the faq pages. Christine korsgaards selfconstitution, journal of moral. But what korsgaard means by selfconstitution is as much selfmaintenance as selfcreation. Korsgaard draws on the work of important figures in the history of philosophy such as plato, aristotle, kant, and hume, showing how their ideas can inform the solution of contemporary and traditional philosophical problems, such as the foundations of morality and practical reason, the nature of agency, and the role of the emotions in action. Korsgaard s latest book, self constitution, develops and defends the broadly kantian account of action and agency that hovers in the background of sources, drawing out its implications for the normative question. Pavkovic explores how national selfdetermination, in the form of creation of a new state through secession, could override the principles of majority rule and of equal rights, which are primary liberal principles. Love, selfconstitution, and practical necessity ideals. Article on the right to external self determination. Constitution has the same conclusion as the sources, that is, roughly. Plato and kant advance a constitutional model of the soul, in which reason and passion have different functional roles in the generation of motivation, as opposed to humes combat model in which they are portrayed as independent sources of motivation struggling for control.
Selfdefense is a constitutional right the washington post. Korsgaard develops a theory of action and of interaction, and of the form interaction must take if we are to have the integrity that, she argues, is essential for agency. Korsgaard s contention is that frankfurtstyle accounts of personhood square nicely with utilitarianism, but that her kantian roots demand an account of personhood on which agency and action are central. Two conceptions of agency the original aim of this paper was to throw some light on the question whether, when people act together, there is some way in which they are able to. Commitment and temporal mediation in korsgaards self. Self constitution is the project of identifying and orienting ones life around projects and values of ones choosing.
Korsgaard, selfconstitution in the ethics of plato and. In terms of the constitutional model we may explain what makes an action. Christine korsgaard has proposed an influential answer to this question. This includes the question of how an unwanted state can be imposed upon a. Agency, identity, and integrity, 2009, 245 pages, christine m. One may be driven to achieving balance or consistency in ones beliefs, maintaining stability in. Selfdetermination versus majority ruleequal rights. This book presents an account of the foundation of practical reason and moral obligation. In self constitution christine korsgaard argues that our reasons are public. Selfconsistency t herapy is about changeor, at least, we hope it is.
Christine korsgaard s 1996 book, the sources of normativity, attracted a great deal of attention. This book presents an account of the foundation of practical reason and moral. Few moral philosophers, however, have exploited the idea that actions might be morally good or bad in virtue of being good or bad of their kind good or bad as actions. She has defended a version of this view in her book the sources of normativity 1996, cambridge university press. Love is puzzling because it appears to involve essentially both rational and nonrational phenomena. A territorial interpretation lea brilmayert the phrase selfdeterminationis simply loaded with dyna mite. Korsgaard indicates ones identity to be constituted by ones choices and actions p. This reorientation has far ranging implications for the ethics of behavioral policies in general and lp.
1171 510 1087 241 1031 430 1017 146 964 1147 50 532 809 47 128 89 529 1075 784 1271 1479 595 1519 1097 809 1128 772 637 130 1161 336 680 528 1476 8 1240 1355 1365 16 872 1495 488 1212 224 215 570 27 529 48